Twitter’s recent housecleaning of some 70 million fake and automated accounts illuminates just how pervasive audience manipulation has become in the digital era. For Twitter, the fake accounts can create a shadow army of followers that has comparatively little monetary effect. But perform the same manipulation with music streams, and it constitutes fraud.
By Cherie Hu
LOS ANGELES (Variety) –
Tidal has found itself awash in accusations of data manipulation. As recently as May, Norwegian newspaper Dagens Næringsliv and the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU) accused the Jay-Z-owned service of falsifying tens of millions of streams for Beyoncé’s “Lemonade” and Kanye West’s “The Life of Pablo” albums. While has denied the claims on multiple fronts, a company rep tells Variety that several investigators are currently on the ground at the company’s offices looking into a potential data breach.
Fraud is applicable because there’s a tangible price tag involved in the consumption of a song: Labels and other rights owners are paid on a pro-rata basis, according to proportional volumes of on-demand streams. The average per-stream payout may not look like much — $0.004 for Spotify, slightly more for services like Apple Music and Tidal ($0.008 and $0.012, respectively), although exact rates depend on the type of artist or song.
But they can add up. A top hit like Ed Sheeran’s 2017 monster “Shape of You” would distribute millions of dollars in performance royalties to its songwriters and even more to the master-rights owner. Using Goldman Sachs’ projection that the streaming sector will hit $34 billion by 2030, millions of dollars in fraudulently acquired funds could be making their way through the royalty chain. Though unlike Twitter, which wiped out 6% of its users, the number of fake music streamers has not been determined. Says one major label head: “It’s not something we’re currently concerned about, but that’s not to say we won’t be in the future.”
Here’s how “playola” works at playlist-promotion companies like Spotlister: A customer pays the company to secure prominent placement of a song on key playlists, such as those on . When a track is uploaded, it is analyzed and its metadata is used to send it to the most appropriate playlists.
But that’s not the only way to game the system. In 2017, Post Malone’s label, Republic Records, found itself the center of controversy for a seemingly sanctioned loop of the hook to his song “Rockstar” that was posted on YouTube. Although it contained only a snippet of the tune, it played continuously for three minutes and 28 seconds and quickly racked up more than 40 million views.
“It’s pretty easy to buy guides online on how to stream your own content repeatedly.”
Christine Barnum, CD Baby director of finance
Two months later, YouTube acknowledged, “Loop videos that feature misleading and inaccurate metadata violate YouTube policies, and we are actively working to have them removed.”
Spotify has kicked outlets like Spotlister off its platform on a case-by-case basis — stand-alone sites like Social Media Experts, Streamify and StreamKO offer “Spotify promotion” with prices ranging from $5 to $995 — but concerns remain about whether that enforcement is being replicated meaningfully across entire platforms. And if not, are the labels or the streamers themselves complicit in royalty fraud by transferring payouts? The legal consequences for fraud convictions, and even of conspiracy to defraud, include hefty fines and up to five years in prison.
“We’re seeing an uptick in the type of fraud where people are distributing their content through us and signing up with a legitimate credit card, but then their intent is to manipulate streams and rip off a [digital service provider],” Christine Barnum, director of finance at CD Baby, tells Variety. “It’s pretty easy to buy guides online on how to stream your own content repeatedly. There are also more instances of well-meaning artists accidentally signing up for some sort of ‘marketing service’ that’s actually committing fraud.”
Moreover, on Spotify’s free tier, ad fraud is also becoming more prevalent. Spotify had to decrease its total reported content hours streamed in 2017 by 500 million, due to 2 million listeners who used unauthorized apps that blocked ads on the service. With freemium, there is “not only more susceptibility to fraud but also less incentive for Spotify to do something about it,” argues Rami Essaid, CEO of bot-defense start-up Distil Networks. “With the subscription model, there’s a finite number of dollars to split up, and if part of that goes to fraud, no one else in the ecosystem is happy.”
For its part, Spotify stated in a just-released second-quarter earnings report, “We continue to work to identify and remove users from our reported metrics that we consider to be ‘fake’ users based on various criteria,” with the caveat that “some such users may remain in our reported metrics because of the limitations of our ability to identify their accounts.”
Experian’s quarterly revenue rises 4% on North America boost
Australia watchdog says Vodafone misled customers over digital purchases
Indonesia drafting rules to apply VAT on online products and services
Norway’s Telenor flags lower earnings on dismal Asian businesses
MLB roundup: Rays’ d’Arnaud hits 3 HRs to beat Yanks
Facebook’s cryptocurrency ambitions face privacy concerns, political backlash
Huawei says U.S. ban hurting more than expected, to wipe $30 billion off revenue
Electric dreams in danger as funding dwindles for China’s Tesla challengers
U.S. reach World Cup final with dramatic win over England
Slack stock surges at debut, values company at more than $23 billion
Investigation: One in Three Reviews on TripAdvisor Are Fake
Amazon Selling its own Mattresses
Roy Moore Sues Sacha Baron Cohen for $95 Million
A Tesla Surf Board? Yes, Tesla Invented a Surfboard
Tom Cruise, James Corden ‘Fall Out’ of Plane on ‘Late Late Show’ (Watch)
ENTERTAINMENT4 months ago
Can You Name the Celebrity from the ’90s Photo?
LIFE1 year ago
Russia Is Very Different Than You Thought
LIFE4 months ago
How well do you know European club football?
Sports11 months ago
29 Things You Need To Know About The Tiger Woods Comeback!
ENTERTAINMENT1 year ago
38 Photos Taken Moments Before Disaster Struck
ENTERTAINMENT3 years ago
This Guy Transformed His Ugly Backyard Into a Pool Paradise!
ENTERTAINMENT3 years ago
Just What Happened To These Stars of 80’s & 90’s Wrestling?
ENTERTAINMENT3 years ago
Insanely Funny Food Brands From Around The World
Sports10 months ago
Nike’s Colin Kaepernick Ad reactions range from support to outrage
ENTERTAINMENT2 years ago
The Oversized Monsters Of The Animal World # 15 Will Freak You Out